You got hurt at work, but you already had a bad back, a weak knee, or another health problem. Now you are scared your employer or insurer will use that against you. They often try. They say your pain comes from your old problem, not from the job. That can shrink or even block your claim. You deserve truth, not pressure. This guide explains how preexisting conditions affect your workers’ compensation claim and what you can do to protect yourself. You will see how insurers look at your medical history. You will learn what proof matters most. You will also see when workers’ compensation attorneys can help you fight blame and delay. You are not asking for a gift. You are asking for the law to work the way it should. Your health, your pay, and your future are on the line.
What counts as a preexisting condition
A preexisting condition is any health problem you had before your work injury. It can be old or recent. It can be from another job, a car crash, sports, or daily life.
Common examples include:
- Back pain or prior spine surgery
- Arthritis in knees, hips, or hands
- Old shoulder tears or rotator cuff problems
- Asthma or breathing trouble
- Heart disease
- Depression, anxiety, or PTSD
The law in many states accepts that workers come to the job with these problems. The job must take you as you are. If work makes your condition worse, that can still be a covered injury. The key question is simple. Did your job cause a new injury or make your old condition worse in a clear way.
How insurers use your medical history
Insurers look for reasons to cut their costs. Your medical history is one of the first things they study. They look for any record that lets them say your pain is old.
They often:
- Request years of records from your doctors
- Highlight old complaints that sound like your new symptoms
- Point to gaps in care and say you must be fine now
- Send you to an insurance doctor for a one time review
You do not need to hide your history. That can hurt you. You do need to give clear facts. You also need to show how your life changed after the work injury. Federal research shows that clear records and early care help injured workers return to work with better long term health. For example, see guidance from the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health at https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/injury/.
New injury versus aggravation of an old condition
Work injuries with preexisting conditions usually fall into three groups. Each group affects your claim in a different way.
| Type of work injury | Simple example | Common insurer response | What you must show
|
|---|---|---|---|
| New injury with no link to old problem | You have old knee arthritis. A heavy box falls on your hand and breaks a finger. | Often accepts claim for hand. Tries to ignore knee. | Show clear link between accident and new body part. |
| Aggravation of old condition | You have mild back pain. A fall at work leads to sharp pain and new limits. | Claims all pain is from your old back. | Show that pain, limits, and needed care got worse after the event. |
| Combination of old and new injuries | You have prior neck strain. A crash in a work truck causes a new herniated disc. | Tries to split blame between old and new problems. | Show that the work event caused a clear new diagnosis. |
Many states treat a clear aggravation of an old condition as a new work injury. That can give you benefits. That includes medical care and wage loss. You do not need a perfect body to qualify.
Why honest reporting matters
Fear can push you to hide old problems. That choice can cost you your claim.
Always:
- Tell your employer about the injury right away
- Describe what happened at work in plain detail
- Tell your doctor about both your old problems and the new event
- Use the same story every time
Inconsistency gives insurers an excuse to say you are not honest. That can lead to denial or long delay. Truth gives your claim strength. It also helps your doctor give safe care. The United States Department of Labor explains that prompt and accurate injury reports support fair claims under workers compensation laws. You can read more at https://www.dol.gov/general/topic/workcomp.
Proof that can support your claim
Words alone rarely change an insurer’s mind. You need proof that shows a clear change after the work event. Focus on three simple types of proof.
First, medical records.
- Office notes that compare your old limits and new limits
- Test results that show a new tear, fracture, or disc problem
- Doctor opinions that use “work aggravated” or “work caused” language
Second, work records.
- Accident reports
- Witness statements from co workers
- Job duty lists that show lifting, bending, or other strain
Third, everyday evidence.
- Notes from family about how you moved before and after the injury
- Photos or videos that show you at work or at home
- Personal journal entries on pain and sleep
These details tell a simple story. You had a level of function before the injury. You have a lower level of function after the injury. That change is what the law cares about.
Common problems you might face
When you have a preexisting condition, you may run into the same problems many workers face.
- Delayed approval of tests or surgery
- Denial letters that blame your age or old injuries
- Pressure to return to work before you feel safe
- Confusing medical exams with insurance doctors
You can respond in three steps. You can keep all letters and notes. You can attend every medical visit and follow treatment. You can ask questions any time something feels rushed or unfair. Calm pressure from you can stop quiet denial.
When to seek legal help
You may need legal help when:
- Your claim is denied because of your old condition
- Your checks stop without clear reason
- The insurer fights needed care that your doctor ordered
- You feel pushed to settle before you understand your rights
Workers’ compensation attorneys speak the language of insurers. They know how to use your records and history in a strong way. They can request hearings, call witnesses, and question insurance doctors. You still make the choices. You gain support and a clear plan.
Key steps you can take today
You cannot change your medical past. You can control how you respond now. Three actions matter most.
- Report the injury and give a full, honest history
- Stay in steady contact with your doctor and follow the plan
- Keep records and seek advice if the insurer blames your old condition
Your body carries your whole life story. The law does not erase that story. It can still protect you when work adds new harm. You deserve steady care, fair pay, and clear answers while you heal.
Our dedicated team gathers information from all the reliable sources to make the law accessible and understandable for everyone. We provide the latest legal news stories from across the country, delivered straight to you.