In the United States, threatening someone with violence is not protected by free speech it can be a serious criminal offense. While many people think “it’s just words,” the law treats threats differently when they create fear, show intent, or are credible enough to cause harm. Depending on the circumstances, you can absolutely go to jail for threatening someone with violence.
When a Threat Becomes a Crime
Under U.S. law, not every angry statement or insult qualifies as a criminal threat. To be punishable, a threat generally must meet specific legal standards. Although laws vary by state, most require three elements:
- A clear and specific threat to cause physical harm or death;
- An intent to make the victim believe the threat will be carried out; and
- A reasonable fear on the part of the victim.
In other words, a vague or emotional statement like “I’m so mad at you” isn’t criminal—but saying “I’m going to come to your house tonight and hurt you” very well could be.
Federal vs. State Laws on Threats
Both federal and state laws prohibit violent threats, especially when they cross certain lines.
- At the federal level, 18 U.S.C. § 875 makes it a crime to transmit threats of injury or death through interstate communication—including text messages, social media, emails, or phone calls. Violating this law can lead to up to 5 years in federal prison for each offense.
- At the state level, laws differ slightly but often fall under “terroristic threats,” “criminal threats,” or “assault by threat.” These can be charged as misdemeanors or felonies depending on the seriousness, the target, and the defendant’s intent.
For example:
- In California, making a criminal threat (Penal Code §422) can result in up to 3 years in state prison.
- In Texas, a “terroristic threat” charge can range from a Class B misdemeanor (up to 180 days in jail) to a third-degree felony (up to 10 years in prison) if the threat causes public fear or disrupts government operations.
Online and Social Media Threats
In today’s digital world, threats made online or through social media are taken just as seriously as those made in person. Posting a message or sending a DM like “I’m going to shoot you” or “I’ll blow up your car” can quickly trigger a law enforcement investigation.
The FBI and local police frequently investigate online threats—especially if they involve schools, workplaces, or public figures. Even if you never intended to follow through, prosecutors can still file charges if your message caused fear or disrupted public safety.
Courts have repeatedly ruled that “true threats” are not protected under the First Amendment. In contrast, “political hyperbole” or general expressions of anger might be protected—but that’s a thin line that often gets decided in court.
Verbal Threats vs. Conditional Threats
There’s also a legal distinction between verbal threats and conditional threats.
- A verbal threat (“I’m going to beat you up right now”) is immediate and direct.
- A conditional threat (“If you don’t pay me, I’ll hurt you”) ties violence to a condition and may constitute extortion or coercion—both serious felonies.
Even if no physical contact occurs, the threat itself can be criminal. Prosecutors don’t need proof that you could or would actually carry it out—just that you made the victim reasonably fear harm.
Possible Defenses
Every case depends on context and intent. Common defenses include:
- Lack of intent: The words were spoken in anger without real intention to harm.
- No reasonable fear: The recipient didn’t actually believe the threat was real.
- Free speech: The statement was opinion, exaggeration, or not a “true threat.”
However, these defenses are not always easy to prove—especially if the threat was specific or accompanied by actions suggesting intent (like showing a weapon, following the victim, or posting personal information online).
Consequences of Making a Threat
Threatening someone with violence can lead to:
- Arrest and criminal charges (misdemeanor or felony)
- Jail or prison time
- Fines and restitution
- Restraining orders or loss of firearm rights
- A permanent criminal record
Even if you avoid jail, a conviction can affect your employment, professional licensing, and ability to own or carry a firearm.
The Bottom Line
Yes—you can go to jail for threatening someone with violence. Whether it’s said face-to-face, over the phone, or online, a threat that causes reasonable fear of harm is a crime. The First Amendment does not protect violent or credible threats.
If you’re facing charges or being accused of making a threat, consult a criminal defense attorney immediately. What you say—and how you say it—can mean the difference between freedom and a felony record.
Our dedicated team gathers information from all the reliable sources to make the law accessible and understandable for everyone. We provide the latest legal news stories from across the country, delivered straight to you.